American Ginseng vs. Ginseng: A Clear Guide to Their Benefits and Uses

Introduction to American Ginseng and Ginseng

American ginseng (Panax quinquefolium) and Ren Shen (ginseng, Panax ginseng) are two revered herbs in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), prized for their tonic properties. American ginseng, native to North America and cultivated in Canada, the U.S., and recently China, was introduced to Chinese medicine during the Qing Dynasty. Ren Shen, primarily grown in China’s Jilin Province and South Korea, has been a cornerstone of TCM for centuries. While both herbs boost vitality, their properties, effects, and applications differ significantly, making them suited to distinct health needs.

Historical Significance

Ancient TCM texts praise both herbs for their restorative powers. The Compendium of Materia Medica describes American ginseng as sweet, slightly bitter, and cool, nourishing Yin, clearing heat, and promoting body fluids. The New Compendium of Materia Medica highlights its ability to reduce internal fire, relieve fatigue, and hydrate the body. Ren Shen, noted for its warming and energizing effects, is celebrated for replenishing vital energy (Qi) and supporting overall vitality. These historical insights underscore their unique roles in TCM.

Ginseng

Botanical Characteristics

American Ginseng

American ginseng is a perennial herb with a smooth, hairless appearance. Its root is hammer-shaped, cylindrical, or conical, measuring 3–12 cm long and 0.8–2 cm in diameter. The surface is light yellow-brown or yellow-white, marked by transverse rings, fine wrinkles, and root scars.

The cross-section is light yellow-white, slightly powdery, with brown-yellow resin channels and radial textures. It has a subtle, unique aroma and a slightly bitter-sweet taste.

Ren Shen (Ginseng)

Ren Shen’s main root is hammer-shaped or cylindrical, with 2–3 lateral roots and fine, hair-like roots that may show small wart-like protrusions. Its texture and appearance vary depending on processing.

Red Ginseng

Red ginseng, a steamed form of Ren Shen, is reddish-brown, hard, and horn-like in cross-section, with a distinct warm nature compared to unprocessed ginseng.

American Ginseng vs. Ginseng

Key Differences Between American Ginseng, Ren Shen, and Red Ginseng

Appearance

• American Ginseng: Cylindrical or conical, light yellow-brown, with transverse rings.

• Ren Shen: Cylindrical with fine hair-like roots and occasional wart-like protrusions.

• Red Ginseng: Reddish-brown, hard, and glossy due to steaming.

Origin

• American Ginseng: Primarily from the U.S., Canada, and now China.

• Ren Shen: Mainly from Jilin, China, and South Korea.

• Red Ginseng: Produced in China and South Korea.

American Ginseng vs. Ginseng

Flavor and Nature

• American Ginseng: Sweet, slightly bitter, cool; acts on lung and stomach meridians.

• Ren Shen: Sweet, slightly bitter, slightly warm; acts on spleen and lung meridians.

• Red Ginseng: Sweet, slightly bitter, warm; acts on spleen and lung meridians.

Functions

• American Ginseng: Nourishes Yin, clears heat, and promotes body fluids.

• Ren Shen: Replenishes Qi, boosts vitality, and supports body fluid production.

• Red Ginseng: Warms and boosts Yang, providing a stronger tonic effect.

  
  

American Ginseng vs. Ginseng

Efficacy and Uses: American Ginseng vs. Ginseng

American Ginseng

American ginseng’s cool nature makes it ideal for conditions involving Yin deficiency and excess heat. Its benefits include:

• Replenishing Qi and Nourishing Yin: Enhances energy and combats fatigue in cases of Qi and Yin deficiency.

• Clearing Heat and Hydrating: Relieves internal heat, cough, asthma, dry mouth, thirst, and fatigue.

• Anti-Fatigue: Boosts endurance and resilience.

• Antioxidant: Slows cell aging.

• Anti-Stress: Improves tolerance to stress, such as low oxygen or cold environments.

• Blood Sugar Regulation: Supports diabetes management.

Usage: Take 3–6 grams daily via decoction, tea, wine, or direct consumption. Best in spring and summer due to its cooling properties.

Ginseng Extract 5:1 Concentrated Granules

Buy Now

Ren Shen (Ginseng)

Ren Shen’s warm nature suits Qi deficiency and conditions requiring vitality restoration. Its benefits include:

• Replenishing Qi: Treats weakness, spleen or lung Qi deficiency, and low energy.

• Promoting Body Fluids: Alleviates thirst and fluid loss.

• Calming the Mind: Eases restlessness, insomnia, and nightmares.

• Boosting Yang: Supports overall vitality, especially in colder seasons.

Usage: Take 3–9 grams daily in soups, teas, wines, or directly. Ideal for autumn and winter, particularly for those with robust constitutions. Avoid long-term high doses to prevent overstimulation.

Ginseng Nutritive Comb, Ren Shen Yang Rong Tang/人參養榮湯, 5:1 Concentrated Granules

Buy Now

Red Ginseng

Red ginseng, with its pronounced warming effect, is used for severe Qi deficiency or Yang depletion, offering stronger tonic benefits than unprocessed Ren Shen.

American Ginseng vs. Ginseng

Modern Applications

American Ginseng

In modern medicine, American ginseng is used for:

• Yin Deficiency with Excess Fire: Treats symptoms like cough, bloody sputum, thirst, and dry mouth.

• Diabetes: Helps regulate blood sugar.

• Cardiovascular Health: Protects the heart through antioxidant and anti-stress effects.

• Immune Support: Enhances resistance to infections.

Ginseng

Ren Shen is applied in cases of:

• Chronic Fatigue: Boosts energy in Qi-deficient patients.

• Respiratory Issues: Supports lung function in chronic conditions.

• Mental Health: Improves focus and reduces anxiety in Qi-related disorders.

Gingseng

Precautions and Guidelines

American Ginseng

• Who Should Avoid: People with cold spleen/stomach, loose stools, low libido, dysmenorrhea, amenorrhea, or excessive vaginal discharge, as its cooling nature may worsen these conditions.

• Dosage: 3–6 grams daily; avoid overuse.

• Seasonality: Best in spring/summer; avoid in autumn/winter.

Ren Shen

• Who Should Avoid: Those with heat conditions or excessive Yang, as its warming nature may cause overstimulation.

• Dosage: 3–9 grams daily; avoid long-term high doses to prevent side effects like irritability.

• Seasonality: Best in autumn/winter.

General Notes

• Consult a TCM practitioner to ensure proper use based on your constitution.

• Avoid combining with stimulants like coffee or tea, which may reduce efficacy.

Conclusion

American ginseng and Ren Shen are powerful TCM herbs with distinct roles. American ginseng excels at nourishing Yin, clearing heat, and hydrating, making it ideal for heat-related and Yin-deficient conditions.

Ginseng, with its warming and Qi-boosting properties, is perfect for restoring vitality and combating fatigue. By understanding their differences and applications, you can choose the right herb to support your health needs, whether it’s cooling relief in summer or warming energy in winter.

Chinese Name	人參
Chinese Pinyin	Renshen
English Name	Ginseng Root
Latin Pharmaceutical Name	Ginseng Radix et Rhizoma
Category	Roots and rhizomes
Origin	The dried root and rhizome of Panax ginseng C. A. Mey.(Araliaceae) (cultivated).
Production Regions	Primarily produced in the Chinese provinces of Jilin, Liaoning, Heilongjiang.
Macroscopic Features	Sun-dried ginseng: Root is fusiform or cylindrical, 3~15cm long, 1~2cm diameter. Externally grayish-yellow, upper portion or whole body has loose and shallow intermittent thick horizontal lines and obvious longitudinal wrinkles, lower portion has 2~3 lateral roots, with numerous thin and long rootlets which have unobvious tiny verruca. Rhizome is 1~4cm long, 0.3~ 1.5 cm diameter, often twisted and curved, with adventitious roots and loose indented stem scars. Relatively hard texture, fractured surface is pale yellowish-white, powdery, cambium rings are brownish-yellow, cortex has yellowish-brown spotted resin canal and radial cracks. Distinctive odor, slightly bitter, sweet taste. Wild ginseng: main root and rhizome is equally long or relatively short, “人”shaped, rhombus or cylindrical, 2~10cm long. Externally grayish-yellow, with longitudinal wrinkles, upper portion has dense deep ringed horizontal lines, often has 2 lateral roots, rootlets is thin and long, clear and not messed, with obvious verruca. Rhizome is thin and long, upper portion has dense stem scars, adventitious root is relatively thick, similar to jujube seed. Wild ginseng pieces: spherical or sub-spherical thin pieces, externally grayish-white, with “chrysanthemum lines,” powdery, light in weight, brittle texture. Distinctively aromatic odor.
Quality Requirements	Superior medicinal material has thick strip, hard texture, thin skin, without broken.
Properties	Neutral; sweet and slightly bitter taste, slightly warm.
Functions	Greatly supplements original qi, restores the pulse, secures desertion, supplements the spleen, benefits the lung, engenders body fluids, stops thirst, quiets the spirit, promotes intelligence. Apply to complete exhaustion due to physical weakness, cold limbs and weak pulse, poor appetite due to splenic deficiency, coughing with asthma due to pulmondeficiency, hydrodipsia due to depletion of body fluids, feverish dysphoria and diabetes, deficiency and weakness due to invalidism, palpitation and insomnia, impotence and uterus cold, cardiac failure, cardiogenic shock.
Processed Form	White ginseng (sweet ginseng): Often use the Korean red ginseng with short body, relatively inferior texture, boiled in water, soak in sugar water, then sun-dry. The nature has most neutral nature, relatively less effects; apply to supplement the spleen and lung. Red ginseng: steam ginseng with high temperature for 2h until it completely cooked, remove the rootlets after dried, press into irregular square cylindrical shape. it has effect of warm-supplement. Still has nature of vigorous warm and dry while supplementing qi; advanced in excite yang qi, apply to emergency treatment and rescue yang. Organic ginseng: no pesticide residue, no chemical fertilizer, no transgenosis cultivated. Maximally retained the composition and effect of ginseng.
Technical Terms	'Neck': This refers to the remnants of rhizome seen on the apex of root medicinal materials, it is a feature used in the differentiation of medicinal materials. 'Stem scar': this refers to the numerous rounds or semi-circular concave scars of withered stems that can be seen on the 'neck'; that are shaped like small bowls. 'Iron wire striations': this refers to dark-colored, round striations that are present on the outer surface of the upper portion of the taproot of wild ginseng, it is a diagnostic feature used in the identification of wild ginseng. 'Pearl dots': this refers to small protuberances on the fine rootlets of wild ginseng; these areas also called 'pearl bumps'.
Remark	Ginseng (Panax ginseng) is listed in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) Appendix II. Its trade is allowed but subject to licensing controls.